-
16th-October-2010 #1
Sperm donor anonymity case to proceed
Sperm donor anonymity case to proceed
Last Updated: Friday, October 15, 2010 | 5:55 PM PT Comments33Recommend10
The Canadian Press
Shirley Pratten, the mother of plaintiff Olivia Pratten, says they suspect sperm-donation records purportedly destroyed might still exist. (CBC) A 28-year-old woman conceived through sperm donation has won the right to proceed with a lawsuit aimed at getting information about the donor.
A B.C. Supreme Court judge has rejected a bid by the provincial government to block a lawsuit filed by Olivia Pratten, who was born in B.C. but now lives in Toronto.
Pratten wants the court to order the province to create a system that ensures sperm donor records are kept indefinitely and to prevent existing records from being destroyed.
Pratten, who said she's thrilled the suit will proceed, has been fighting for more than a decade to obtain records about her conception, arguing such information is vital to her own health.
The doctor who oversaw the sperm donation procedure for Pratten's mother insisted in court that he destroyed the relevant documents in the 1990s because physicians aren't required to keep patient records for more than six years.
Pratten and her mother don't believe the documents were actually destroyed, pointing to what they believe are inconsistencies in what the now-retired doctor has told them.
Read more: CBC News - British Columbia - Sperm donor anonymity case to proceed
-
17th-October-2010 #2
Re: Sperm donor anonymity case to proceed
What the fuck?!
I smell bullshit!
She's just look for a guy to sponge off of, if this goes though then I don't think there will be to many men who will donate to sperm banks and right so, this is just more anti male bullshit, I hope this bitch get's cancer and dies a slow lingering death!
Ya I'm pissed off and any normal and right thinking man would be so as well.When the femanazis tell me it's their way or the highway I tell them to fuck off and die, because at lest the highway leads to new and intresting places, their ways is a dead end.
-
17th-October-2010 #3
Re: Sperm donor anonymity case to proceed
What a parasite!
Getting access to sperm donor records isn't vital for her health, its vital to her bank account!
Greed is for amateurs.
Knowledge without wisdom is a load of books on the back of an ass.
Scorn and mockery towards men in need is one of the reasons feminism is dying as we speak!.
-
Re: Sperm donor anonymity case to proceed
I believe she has a right (just as a 'he' would if it were a male we were talking about) has a right to medical backgrounds. Nonetheless, I understood that sperm donors were inspected from top to bottom and only the best of the best were fully accepted for donations.
-
17th-October-2010 #5
Re: Sperm donor anonymity case to proceed
Thanks for this. I'm going to add it to other links that show the build up to this and write a post. Now I just have to find them, lol.
Ignorance is the Oppressor, Vigilance the Liberator.
-
Re: Sperm donor anonymity case to proceed
freeloaders leave no stone unturned looking for unearned largesse - there is a culprit out there somewhere - she muses - who can be made to pay
-
17th-October-2010 #7
Re: Sperm donor anonymity case to proceed
I would like to know what this has to do with her health. The article seems a bit vague as to the details.
~Politicians are just a group of lawyers over complicating life for everyone else.
~Political correctness is tyranny with manners. - Charlton Heston (1924-)
-
17th-October-2010 #8
Re: Sperm donor anonymity case to proceed
Greed is for amateurs.
Knowledge without wisdom is a load of books on the back of an ass.
Scorn and mockery towards men in need is one of the reasons feminism is dying as we speak!.
-
17th-October-2010 #9
Re: Sperm donor anonymity case to proceed
Here's the extra I was looking for. (wrote my post on it)
Sperm-donors’ kids seek more rights, respect
Washington Post August 16, 2010
Katrina Clark and Lindsay Greenawalt have much in common. Bright women in their 20s, raised by single mothers, keenly curious about the men whose donated sperm helped give them life. They want to transform the dynamics of sperm donation so the children’s interests are given more weight and it becomes easier to learn about their biological fathers. One specific goal – a ban on anonymous sperm donations – seems far-off in the United States…A new film, “The Kids Are All Right,” depicts two teenage siblings who track down their sperm-donor father and introduce him to their lesbian moms. Complications ensue, but the teens’ yearning to meet their dad is portrayed empathetically. The film opened just weeks after the release of a provocative study by the Commission on Parenthood’s Future, titled “My Daddy’s Name is Donor.” It surveyed 485 donor offspring, concluded they were more troubled and depression-prone than other young adults in comparison groups, and recommended an end to anonymous sperm donation. READ MOREIgnorance is the Oppressor, Vigilance the Liberator.
-
17th-October-2010 #10
Re: Sperm donor anonymity case to proceed
are they saying kids with-out fathers are more troubled and depressed?concluded they were more troubled and depression-prone than other young adults in comparison groups,
WOW-this is news-who wudda thought?
has nothing to do with anonymous sperm donations-has everything to do with the lack of a father figure.and recommended an end to anonymous sperm donation.
i wonder if kids from divorced families with no dad around were included in this study?
-
17th-October-2010 #11
Re: Sperm donor anonymity case to proceed
Now they are playing " In the best intrests of the children. " card, if women and the govrement really gave a damn about the children whey would have pimp handed the femanazis back in the stone age and not destoryed a man's roll as a father or allowed all the anti male horse shit to be passed in law and in socity nor would the females become women but would have remained ladies and that the male headede household and the tradisnaol male/female roles would have remained intact.
I hear you Bro, it never ceicess to amaze me at the sheer stupidy people as well as the bullshit that men and boys have to face
Nailed it in one and of coruse the children from divorced familes were never taken into consideration since it would show what the Real Promlem is and not this bullshit excuse to take away a man's rights and freedoms.has nothing to do with anonymous sperm donations-has everything to do with the lack of a father figure.
i wonder if kids from divorced families with no dad around were included in this study?When the femanazis tell me it's their way or the highway I tell them to fuck off and die, because at lest the highway leads to new and intresting places, their ways is a dead end.
-
17th-October-2010 #12
Re: Sperm donor anonymity case to proceed
Here is the deal how I see it:
Instead of looking at the mothers in these situations and saying "hey, how come you didnt have a relationship with someone and let them have a relationship with your kids so your kids could know them and have a father in their lives" there is an effort to find some dude who jerked off in a cup twenty some years prior and tell him "YOURE RESPONSIBLE SIMPLY BECAUSE YOU HAVE A DICK AND YOU REACHED A STATE OF ORGASIM"!!
Again, we simply will not as a society make women responsible for their reproductive choices and indeed give them more and more choices but we will stop at nothing to make the father.....er....a...sperm donor responsible.Do not ever suppose that a small group of people can never change the world. INDEED it is the only thing that ever has.
Anonymous.




Reply With Quote







Bookmarks