This is a discussion on Female accuser should be charged, says lawyer of Haverhill man cleared of rape convic within the False Allegations forums, part of the General category; As I read this article, I found so many egregious points that I was not sure what, if any, introduction ...
| | ||||||
| Register | Support Network | Blogs | FAQ | Members List | Calendar | Search | Today's Posts | Mark Forums Read |
|
#1
| ||||
| ||||
Female accuser should be charged, says lawyer of Haverhill man ... Eagle Tribune - North Andover,MA,USA Female accuser should be charged, says lawyer of Haverhill man cleared of rape conviction By Shawn Regan sregan@eagletribune.com New Hampshire has dropped all charges against Roland "Chris" Chretien of Haverhill, who was convicted in 2004 of sexually assaulting a 46-year-old female customer inside his Plaistow motorcycle shop, Blazin' Saddles on Route 125. Chretien's lawyer said he wants legal action against the woman for lying. Chretien was freed by a federal judge in July, after the woman admitted to lying at Chretien's 2004 trial. He had spent almost four years in prison. At the trial, the woman denied she had previously falsely accused another man of raping her under circumstances similar to the Chretien allegations. New Hampshire Attorney General Kelly Ayotte's office has decided not to challenge U.S. Judge Joseph Laplante's decision freeing Chretien and throwing out the 2004 guilty verdict against him. That left it up to Rockingham County Attorney James Reams' office to either retry Chretien or drop the charges against him. Chretien's attorney, Scott Gleason of Haverhill, said Reams' office has dismissed the original indictment against Chretien. Gleason said Chretien is "deeply appreciative" for the county attorney's swift action. However, Chretien now wants to see criminal perjury charges filed by the county attorney against the woman and her husband, whose courtroom lies sent him to prison, Gleason said. "My client is demanding criminal charges for the perjury that resulted in his financial destruction and him spending four years behind bars for a crime he didn't commit," Gleason said. Gleason said he is in "negotiations for prosecution" of the woman with the county attorney's office. Other options include asking federal authorities to intervene and filing a civil lawsuit for monetary damages against the woman and her husband, Gleason said. "Her husband lied throughout the trial about not knowing his wife was having multiple sexual affairs," Gleason said. "He has since admitted he knew of at least two affairs." At the 2004 trial, Judge Kenneth McHugh refused to allow Chretien's lawyer to ask the woman about her accusations or hold a pretrial hearing to probe the matter. McHugh simply asked the woman whether she had falsely accused another man of sexually assaulting her, and took her word that she had not, Gleason said. However, the victim admitted to the prior false rape accusation at a July 8 federal hearing, at which her son and his roommate were prepared to testify about their knowledge of the matter, according to a 16-page ruling released last month by Laplante, the U.S. judge. The ruling does not mention the woman by name. "It was impossible to determine whether the superior court's refusal to allow Chretien to cross-examine the victim regarding an allegedly false accusation of sexual assault against another man had a substantial, injurious effect on the verdict," Laplante wrote. At the criminal trial, the victim testified she had gone to the motorcycle store to buy a leather belt. She told the judge she lives in a constant state of fear since the assault and that she was struggling through therapy and taking medications as a result of it. "When justice is made a travesty, good men must become outlaws." Dylan MacVillain, The poster formerly known as AKUUS | ||||
|
#2
| ||||
| ||||
Oh yes!!!! About time! Out of the gloom a voice spake unto me. 'Smile and be happy, Things could get worse." So I smiled and was happy, and behold... Things did get worse. ►My blog / Your Blog ►Please use the TAGS to help organise the content - found at the bottom of every thread ►If you have found a website that supports predominantly male clients, click here to list it so other men may make use of it. Sorry to say - it's that time again - donations are needed to help support the upkeep of the site. I've been paying the last few installments but cannot reach January's - please donate £10 or whatever you can afford by click the 'Donate' button... | ||||
|
#3
| |||
| |||
How can such injustice and oppression OPENLY go on and on and on, right in front of our eyes? DAMN! Somewhere something HAS to give. It is not possible for things to continue like this in a 'civilized' society. Are there not people reading this news? Why does everyone keep silent? This is the 21st century, such things should NOT be going on. | |||
|
#4
| |||
| |||
So WRITE the author...get the word out...ask questions...update us...count on our support... Ridgefield, Connecticut, USA, Earth, Milky Way, Universe, Creation | |||
|
#5
| ||||
| ||||
Quote:
By Shawn Regan sregan@eagletribune.com I intend to write him later on today or tomorrow. "When justice is made a travesty, good men must become outlaws." Dylan MacVillain, The poster formerly known as AKUUS | ||||
|
#6
| |||
| |||
Mr Regan, I'm down in CT but saw that your article is getting some attention across the country. You may not be aware of this but you are showing incredible bias. A man was falsely accused and jailed for years. But you are still calling his false accuser the victim. The victim is the man here. His life was destroyed by those who lied about him. Thank goodness this did not go on longer. I realize that most likely you disagree with me....but could you at least use the phrase "alleged victim" instead of victim for the woman. Can you imagine the horrors and harm Mr Chretien experienced due to the lies told about him on the stand? HE experienced mental rape if you will, maybe even rape in prison from another inmate. How is he supposed to restart his life now? If the "alleged victim" woman is experiencing issues right now I am sorry to hear that. Haven't you considered that her conscience has been bothering her? And that many clear thinking people now KNOW what she did to another person out of anger? That's the real story here. Stan Ridgefield, Connecticut, USA, Earth, Milky Way, Universe, Creation | |||
|
#7
| ||||
| ||||
My email..... Hi Shawn, An innocent man spent four years in jail due to the lies of a woman and you call her “Victim” are you insane ? Robert. Cain murdered Abel and never batted an eyelid - I wonder what Cain`s descendants do ??? | ||||
|
#8
| |||
| |||
Sending an email to the biased / clueless Mr Regan who wrote the article is not enough. After all he can just laugh and gleefully delete them in a burst of his power rush. ALSO..include some of these fellas: http://www.eagletribune.com/contactus ![]() Al Getler Publisher To contact Al Getler, e-mail him at agetler@eagletribune.com. ![]() Al White Editor To contact Al White for comments on overall editorial content and quality, e-mail him at awhite@ eagletribune.com or call 978-946-2479. ![]() Gretchen Putnam Managing Editor To contact Gretchen Putnam for news coverage of local cities and towns, e-mail her at gputnam@ eagletribune.com or call 978-946-2337. ![]() Jo-Anne Mackenzie New Hampshire Editor To contact Jo-Anne Mackenzie e-mail her at jmackenzie@ eagletribune.com or call 603-421-3875. ![]() Ken Johnson Editorial Page Editor To contact Ken Johnson for letters to the editor, guest columns or questions about the opinion pages, e-mail him at kjohnson@ eagletribune.com or call 978-946-2237. Ridgefield, Connecticut, USA, Earth, Milky Way, Universe, Creation | |||
|
#9
| |||
| |||
"At the 2004 trial, Judge Kenneth McHugh refused to allow Chretien's lawyer to ask the woman about her accusations or hold a pretrial hearing to probe the matter. McHugh simply asked the woman whether she had falsely accused another man of sexually assaulting her, and took her word that she had not, Gleason said." Sounds like yet another morally retarded and criminally incompetent judge needs the sack, a good horsewhipping and a long spell in jail. | |||
|
#10
| |||
| |||
Got a response from Mr Regan: -----Original Message----- From: SRegan@eagletribune.com To: sjmar cy@a ol.com Sent: Fri, 31 Oct 2008 2:05 pm Subject: Re: Chretian "Rape" Article I do not disagree with you. The woman should have always been referred to as the alleged victim. Not sure how a story that quotes the federal judge's decision about her lying and the defendent's lawyer in detail about his strong feelings on the case is biased against Mr. Chretien. Thanks for the note though. By the way, have you seen the two previous stories I wrote about this? They provide much more detail about the case. Also, as far as I know, the woman has not recanted. The reason the charges were dropped is because her credibility is so damaged that prosecutors can't make a case based on her testimony. And my note back to him: Mr. Regan, Thanks for your response. No, I have not seen the prior articles nor any letters to the editor...I will see if I can track them down on the web site. A point here...this latest article in isolation portrays a different tone than the earlier articles may have expressed. It does come across as biased in isolation which is why I wrote in the first place. I'm a male victim of domestic violence so when I see text that seems to indicate bias it really bothers me. FWIW I always try to let folks know that DV is a people issue as it is 50/50 and 33-38% of those seriously injured are men. Bet you didn't know that...as it is not PC to talk about the whole subject. Rather only male on female violence is covered and funded and written about. See: http://www.csulb.edu/~mfiebert/assault.htm Look in your own paper...when a man attacks a woman the title or text might talk about DV. But if a woman attacks a man...if it even makes the paper (most men do not call the police) then it won't be called domestic violence. In my view if in an intimate relationship someone attacks someone else in it...that is DV. No need to check gender. In my case while trying to get help for my assaults I was falsely accused by my now exe. Nothing at all happened to me from her false charges but they deflected all attention away from what she had done. So I got no help at all, was advised that when she attacks again not to call the police (as they will likely arrest the man due to VAWA) and have PTSD. In my town there are still people who think I attacked her but of the six attacks, ALL were one sided and initiated by a female. Sad. Thanks again for your thoughts and efforts. Stan Ridgefield, Connecticut, USA, Earth, Milky Way, Universe, Creation | |||
|
#11
| |||
| |||
And the big guy gets back to me: Dear Mr. Marcewicz, The point you make about referring to the accuser as the "victim" is a valid one, given what is now known about the case. But I reject the notion that our stories exhibit a bias toward the woman or against the man she accused. Rather, we have brought the story forward so that it is now getting wide attention, as your email notes. I should add that in today's story the woman who brought the accusation is referred to as the "accuser" or simply "the woman" in the headline and throughout most of the main body of story. It is only in the final paragraphs, where we reference the ruling by Judge LaPlante that set Mr. Chretien free, that we refer to the woman as the "victim." That is the word used by the judge in his 16-page decision, even though it overturned the conviction. Still, "the woman who told police she was raped," or a similar construction, would have been a better choice of words except where we quote directly from the ruling. Be assured we will continue to follow this story and the possibility that criminal charges will be filed against the woman. Sincerely, Al White Editor Ridgefield, Connecticut, USA, Earth, Milky Way, Universe, Creation | |||
|
#12
| |||
| |||
I will see if I can find out how to contact the Judge who continues to refer to the false accuser as a rape "victim". It seems that the newspaper is trying to be fair...and referred to the woman as the Judge did...which is news by itself. I think they could have done more and hope they do in the future. I just want basic fairness and even handedness. A level playing field. Ridgefield, Connecticut, USA, Earth, Milky Way, Universe, Creation | |||
|
#13
| ||||
| ||||
The story is always the fucking same! It goes something like this "If I accuse some random man of rape, I will get paid and not have to work a single day in my pathetic life." Does this story sound familiar! I've heard it countless times and I'm not impressed!!! | ||||
|
#14
| |||
| |||
Well done guys, good effort. Any feedback however worded always makes the author a little bit more cautious next time they have to deal with that topic. We have to keep pounding against that wall of bias. Make the cracks appear.. | |||
![]() |
| Tags |
| accuser, author, bias, charged, cleared, convic, feedback, female, good, guys, haverhill, lawyer, man, rape, st, tha, time, topic, usa, wall, wi |
| Thread Tools | |
| | ||||||||||
| ||||
| Posted By | For | Type | Date | |
| Men's Rights Blogs | This thread | Refback | 31st-October-2008 05:51 PM | |
| ||||
| Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
| Man cleared of rape sues accuser | frostyboy | False Allegations | 4 | 8th-July-2008 05:35 PM |
| Female teacher cleared of sex charges | Major Tom | Female Pedophiles | 7 | 13th-February-2008 01:06 PM |
| Female Lawyer Pushes for Shared Parenting | Timocrat | Priority News | 1 | 14th-August-2007 06:11 PM |
| Female Lawyer caught red-handed promoting false allegations of incest | Marx | Chit chat (MAIN) | 7 | 4th-June-2007 09:39 PM |
| Anguish of accuser as student president is cleared of rape | Celtic Druid | Chit chat (MAIN) | 5 | 4th-November-2006 01:41 AM |