Men new 'victims' of domestic violence, Indian men are worried about harrassment

Tyrael · #1 26th-November-2006

Quote:

Men new 'victims' of domestic violence

Veenu Sandhu

New Delhi, November 4, 2006

Looks like the tables have been turnedÂ—for a change, the men are running scared.

The helpline at the Save Indian Family Foundation (SIFF) has not stopped ringing in the 10 days that the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act came into force.

The male callers fear "harassment"Â—from womenÂ—under the new law that can put a man behind bars, simply on the basis of a complaint from a woman living under the same roof.

Counsellors taking the helpline calls for SIFF and My Nation are now talking about cases where the male callers are the victims, and the women the perpetrators of violenceÂ—psychological, emotional or verbal.

"Men are now being harassed by their wives with this new weapon," says Swarup Sarkar of SIFF. Supreme Court lawyer Ram Prakash Chugh of the All India Front Against Persecution by Wives corroborates: "All our five helplines are clogged with calls from men being blackmailed with the threat of this new law. Software professionals, doctors, service-class menÂ—everyone is calling," he says.

The most common complaint? The men say that their wives are demanding that they abandon their parents and start living separately. "Domestic violence should be dealt with, but this Act is bound to be misused," says Sarkar, adding that the Act, strangely, does not account for violence by a woman against a woman. He seeks a "domestic harmony act" where both genders are accountable for violence at home.

"An equal gender law would be ideal," agrees Renuka Chowdhury, minister for women and child development. "But there is simply too much physical evidence to prove that it is mainly the woman who suffers at the hands of man."

The misuse of the anti-dowry law made SIFF set up a website (www.498a.org) to counsel and give legal advice to men and their families who have been implicated falsely; it plans to set up a similar website relating to the new Act.

Email vsandhu@hindustantimes.com

Click here for the news article.

Tyrael · #2 26th-November-2006

Quote:

Men new 'victims' of domestic violence

Veenu Sandhu

New Delhi, November 4, 2006

Looks like the tables have been turnedÂ—for a change, the men are running scared.

The helpline at the Save Indian Family Foundation (SIFF) has not stopped ringing in the 10 days that the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act came into force.

The male callers fear "harassment"Â—from womenÂ—under the new law that can put a man behind bars, simply on the basis of a complaint from a woman living under the same roof.

Counsellors taking the helpline calls for SIFF and My Nation are now talking about cases where the male callers are the victims, and the women the perpetrators of violenceÂ—psychological, emotional or verbal.

"Men are now being harassed by their wives with this new weapon," says Swarup Sarkar of SIFF. Supreme Court lawyer Ram Prakash Chugh of the All India Front Against Persecution by Wives corroborates: "All our five helplines are clogged with calls from men being blackmailed with the threat of this new law. Software professionals, doctors, service-class menÂ—everyone is calling," he says.

The most common complaint? The men say that their wives are demanding that they abandon their parents and start living separately. "Domestic violence should be dealt with, but this Act is bound to be misused," says Sarkar, adding that the Act, strangely, does not account for violence by a woman against a woman. He seeks a "domestic harmony act" where both genders are accountable for violence at home.

"An equal gender law would be ideal," agrees Renuka Chowdhury, minister for women and child development. "But there is simply too much physical evidence to prove that it is mainly the woman who suffers at the hands of man."

The misuse of the anti-dowry law made SIFF set up a website (www.498a.org) to counsel and give legal advice to men and their families who have been implicated falsely; it plans to set up a similar website relating to the new Act.

Email vsandhu@hindustantimes.com

Click here for the news article.

Tyrael · #3 26th-November-2006

Quote:

Men new 'victims' of domestic violence

Veenu Sandhu

New Delhi, November 4, 2006

Looks like the tables have been turnedÂ—for a change, the men are running scared.

The helpline at the Save Indian Family Foundation (SIFF) has not stopped ringing in the 10 days that the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act came into force.

The male callers fear "harassment"Â—from womenÂ—under the new law that can put a man behind bars, simply on the basis of a complaint from a woman living under the same roof.

Counsellors taking the helpline calls for SIFF and My Nation are now talking about cases where the male callers are the victims, and the women the perpetrators of violenceÂ—psychological, emotional or verbal.

"Men are now being harassed by their wives with this new weapon," says Swarup Sarkar of SIFF. Supreme Court lawyer Ram Prakash Chugh of the All India Front Against Persecution by Wives corroborates: "All our five helplines are clogged with calls from men being blackmailed with the threat of this new law. Software professionals, doctors, service-class menÂ—everyone is calling," he says.

The most common complaint? The men say that their wives are demanding that they abandon their parents and start living separately. "Domestic violence should be dealt with, but this Act is bound to be misused," says Sarkar, adding that the Act, strangely, does not account for violence by a woman against a woman. He seeks a "domestic harmony act" where both genders are accountable for violence at home.

"An equal gender law would be ideal," agrees Renuka Chowdhury, minister for women and child development. "But there is simply too much physical evidence to prove that it is mainly the woman who suffers at the hands of man."

The misuse of the anti-dowry law made SIFF set up a website (www.498a.org) to counsel and give legal advice to men and their families who have been implicated falsely; it plans to set up a similar website relating to the new Act.

Email vsandhu@hindustantimes.com

Click here for the news article.

Tyrael · #4 26th-November-2006

Quote:

Â“An equal gender law would be ideal,Â” agrees Renuka Chowdhury, minister for women and child development. Â“But there is simply too much physical evidence to prove that it is mainly the woman who suffers at the hands of man.Â”

There are many studies which point out that women initiate violence slightly more then men.
Women are also more likely to kill someone when they are incapacitated, but currently this sadly isn't included as domestic violence.

Tyrael · #5 26th-November-2006

Quote:

Â“An equal gender law would be ideal,Â” agrees Renuka Chowdhury, minister for women and child development. Â“But there is simply too much physical evidence to prove that it is mainly the woman who suffers at the hands of man.Â”

There are many studies which point out that women initiate violence slightly more then men.
Women are also more likely to kill someone when they are incapacitated, but currently this sadly isn't included as domestic violence.

Tyrael · #6 26th-November-2006

Quote:

Â“An equal gender law would be ideal,Â” agrees Renuka Chowdhury, minister for women and child development. Â“But there is simply too much physical evidence to prove that it is mainly the woman who suffers at the hands of man.Â”

There are many studies which point out that women initiate violence slightly more then men.
Women are also more likely to kill someone when they are incapacitated, but currently this sadly isn't included as domestic violence.

Major Tom · #7 26th-November-2006

Quote:

"An equal gender law would be ideal," agrees Renuka Chowdhury, minister for women and child development. "But there is simply too much physical evidence to prove that it is mainly the woman who suffers at the hands of man."

Am I reading this right?

So they aren't going to make an equal gender law because it is 'mainly women who suffer' at the hands of men?

To hell with male victims then?

For ****s sake....

Major Tom · #8 26th-November-2006

Quote:

"An equal gender law would be ideal," agrees Renuka Chowdhury, minister for women and child development. "But there is simply too much physical evidence to prove that it is mainly the woman who suffers at the hands of man."

Am I reading this right?

So they aren't going to make an equal gender law because it is 'mainly women who suffer' at the hands of men?

To hell with male victims then?

For ****s sake....

Major Tom · #9 26th-November-2006

Quote:

"An equal gender law would be ideal," agrees Renuka Chowdhury, minister for women and child development. "But there is simply too much physical evidence to prove that it is mainly the woman who suffers at the hands of man."

Am I reading this right?

So they aren't going to make an equal gender law because it is 'mainly women who suffer' at the hands of men?

To hell with male victims then?

For ****s sake....

Marx · #10 26th-November-2006

We should also be looking at removing the "women and men" from military, religious and other adverts, songs, and all that. Men had to change to include women in everything, even if only one or two women were involved. Using the above logic, men should now remove women from everything because it has mainly been men defending our countries, or mainly men doing most of the work to build societies.